The 2024 NFL Draft made history by seeing six quarterbacks selected in the first 12 picks, leaving the Las Vegas Raiders in a tough spot with pick No. 13. Head coach Antonio Pierce faced the challenging task of choosing between veteran Gardner Minshew, who signed a lucrative deal after stints with the Jaguars, Eagles, and Colts, and young fourth-round pick Aidan O’Connell as the starting quarterback for the upcoming season.
“We’ve seen enough reps,” Pierce stated after two preseason games. “Our guys are not playing in the third preseason game, so we’ll make a decision in the next couple days.” Following a 27-12 loss to Dallas, Pierce wasted no time in naming Minshew as the starter for the 2024 regular season, citing his experience and leadership qualities as deciding factors.
Pierce praised Minshew’s infectious personality, energy, and improved footwork, while also emphasizing the importance of taking care of the football. When comparing Minshew and O’Connell, Pierce highlighted the magical plays Minshew can create but stressed the need for more consistency in decision-making.
In the game against Dallas, Minshew played four drives resulting in mixed outcomes, while O’Connell led four possessions, including a touchdown pass to tight end Harrison Bryant. However, O’Connell’s interception return touchdown for the Cowboys weighed heavily in Pierce’s evaluation, overshadowing his touchdown pass.
Pierce emphasized the need to consider both the good and the bad when evaluating the performances of Minshew and O’Connell, acknowledging the equal opportunities given to both quarterbacks. As a former NFL linebacker, Pierce’s defensive background influences his assessment of the players’ performances and decision-making on the field.
Ultimately, the Raiders will continue to evaluate both quarterbacks as they prepare for the upcoming season, balancing experience with potential and striving for consistency in their starting quarterback choice.