An imagination is a wonderful thing. Steelers fans can already see Brandon Aiyuk, decked out in black and gold, making the game-winning touchdown catch that secures the team’s seventh Super Bowl victory.
The addition of Aiyuk to the Steelers’ roster has sparked hopes of turning this dream into reality. With a roster stronger than last year’s 10-7 squad, Aiyuk from the talented 49ers could be the missing piece needed for a serious Super Bowl run.
However, recent obstacles in a potential trade for Aiyuk have given pause for thought. It’s led to the consideration that the Steelers might actually be better off without Aiyuk.
Here are the reasons why opting out of a deal for Aiyuk could be in the Steelers’ best interest for the 2024 season and beyond.
It’s no secret that the 49ers are demanding a hefty price for Aiyuk. This was apparent during the draft, when the Steelers were rumored to have balked at the 49ers’ trade requests involving either Aiyuk or Deebo Samuel.
The passage of time hasn’t lessened the 49ers’ stance on wanting top value for Aiyuk. Recent rumors indicate that multiple first-round draft picks are on the table, along with a replacement wide receiver. That’s a steep price for a player with no Pro Bowls under his belt.
Financially, signing Aiyuk would require a significant commitment from the Steelers. Aiyuk is likely seeking a deal that would put him among the highest-paid players at his position, though there are reports suggesting he might be willing to take a pay cut in Pittsburgh. However, this could lead to complications when the team inevitably faces the challenge of having two top-dollar wide receivers on the books.
The Steelers already boast a top-tier receiver in George Pickens, who is poised for a breakout season based on his standout performances in training camp. Pickens himself has set high expectations for his performance.
“I’m just trying to be the greatest,” Pickens declared after a practice session.
In that same conversation, Pickens expressed a clear opinion on whether the Steelers need to bring in additional help at receiver (such as Aiyuk).
The decision to forego Aiyuk may indeed be the wisest course of action for the Steelers moving forward. It’s a bold move that could shape the team’s future success on the field. While the dream of Aiyuk in a Steelers uniform may be tantalizing, it’s important to consider the broader implications and potential pitfalls of making such a high-stakes trade.