The Big Blue View staff recently engaged in a thorough discussion about the possibility of the New York Giants trading for quarterback Bryce Young from the Carolina Panthers. The topic was raised in a round table format, allowing each member of the staff to share their opinion on the matter. The consensus was mixed, with varying levels of optimism and skepticism.
One staff member expressed their initial optimism about Young, citing his potential and past success at Alabama. However, they acknowledged his struggles in the NFL and emphasized the need for a nurturing environment for him to thrive. Despite recognizing his upside, they were hesitant about the Giants giving up valuable resources for a quarterback who has yet to prove himself at the professional level.
Another staff member echoed similar sentiments, suggesting that Young’s confidence may be at an all-time low due to his turbulent stint with the Panthers. They emphasized the need for a long-term plan at quarterback for the Giants, whether that involves sticking with Daniel Jones or looking to the draft for a new signal-caller. The idea of taking a risk on a former top pick like Young was intriguing, but the financial implications of his contract raised concerns.
On the other hand, there were doubts about Young’s skill set and size among the staff members. While acknowledging his intelligence and arm talent, they questioned whether he could translate his success from college to the NFL. The financial aspects of acquiring Young, including his hefty contract and the dead cap implications for Carolina, added another layer of complexity to the potential trade.
Ultimately, the decision to pursue a trade for Young will depend on a variety of factors, including the Giants’ long-term vision at quarterback, the cost of acquiring him, and his ability to adapt to a new team. The staff encouraged readers to weigh in on the discussion through a poll included at the end of the article. As the Giants continue to assess their options at quarterback, the possibility of adding a player like Young remains an intriguing but uncertain prospect for the team.
